Robert died on September 25, 1962 and Annie died on July 29, 1969. Both are buried in the New Pine Hill Cemetery in Sicily Island. (Editor's note: tombstone photograph is courtesy of Karen Klemm Pinckard at FindAGrave.com)
The following children were born to the marriage of Robert Leo McCarty and Sarah Ann "Annie" Watson:
- Ethel Carmen
- Charlie J. "Buddy"
- Juanita Ida
- Robert Leo, Jr.